In Defense of E10 PDF Print E-mail
Special
Written by Sabrina Deparine   
Tuesday, 22 September 2009 09:37
Page views: 1288
Countries: Asia, Philippines

The past two weeks has been challenging for ethanol-blended gasoline or E10. Last September 8, The Philippine Daily Inquirer published an article citing Petron’s statement that ethanol gasoline can damage car engines. Specifically, Petron Chairperson and Chief Executive Officer Ramon Ang was quoted as saying that the company has received many reports that the current blend of E10 is highly-corrosive. In particular, it can damage the vehicle’s gas tank, fuel pump, carburetor, and fuel injector.

Ang further said that the root cause ofthis problem is the  fact that the Philippine government did not specify that a dehydrator should be used to get rid of the water content in E10. As such, Petron made a request to the Department of Energy (DOE) to release new guidelines that will help protect Filipino motorists. It  urged DOE to come up with more defined and clearer specifications for ethanol-blended gasoline.

DOE has been able to release a counterargument to this statement made by Petron. According to DOE Director Zenaida Monsada, DOE has been regularly meeting with representatives of oil firms, car manufacturers, and other ethanol players in their effort to improve the alternative fuel programs of the DOE. The department has clearly set internationally-accepted standards for E10 from the start, even before the official start of the mandated blend which was on February 2009.  Monsada further noted that there are a lot of other factors that can lead to the corrosion of car engines.

In relation to this, several key players in the ethanol industry have also voiced out their views on E10. Art Cruz, Marketing Director for Seaoil Philippines, cited that ethanol has been widely-used in other countries as an alternative fuel for a long time. In fact, Brazil, the United Kingdom, and the United States have been using as much as 85% ethanol-blended gasoline Chamber of Automotive Manufacturers of the Philippines Inc. (CAMPI)(E85) and there are no reported problems regarding this. Homer Maranan, Spokesperson for the Chamber of Automotive Manufacturers of the Philippines Inc. (CAMPI) whose members include the different vehicle manufacturers in the country, said that oil companies should also take the initiative to adopt good housekeeping skills from their refineries up to the gasoline stations in order to ensure that there will be no other reasons or causes for the E10 to become corrosive.

Last September 18, the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) released a statement, urging the Filipinos to support locally produced bioethanol . This is because ethanol fuel can help the local automobile industry and the economy to become cleaner and greener. WWF’s defense of E10 is actually quite similar to the  article entitled “Is E10 Corrosive?”, posted here in BiofuelsHub.Com a few months back. The renowned environmentalist group said that all types of gasoline are corrosive and that E10, by itself, does not corrode vehicle gas tanks, fuel injectors, and carburetors. According to Yeb Saño, WWF Climate Change and Energy Program Director, “ethanol in itself is not corrosive”. It only becomes corrosive  if there is  water which can oxidize the gas tank and other steel components of the vehicle. WWF further cited that ethanol can provide the transportation sector with not only cleaner but also cheaper alternative for transportation fuel without requiring expensive and extensive car modifications.

There are a lot of possible scenarios in which water can come into contact with E10. For instance, in refineries, the ethanol storage tanks may have leaks in which water can seep through. The same is true during the course of transporting E10 from the refinery to the gasoline stations and in the gasoline station itself. This is probably one of the reasons why Maranan had commented that oil companies should take the initiative to implement good housekeeping measures and to monitor the compliance and maintenance especially of their blending areas. With good housekeeping and well-monitored and maintained environment, E10 contamination can be minimized or prevented.



Share this Article.

 
Comments
Add New Search
Eduardo M. Daquil Jr.  - Mr.   |2009-09-28 14:45:05
It is surprising to know top people making conclusive statement without going
thru the root.
All fuels either derived from petroleum or biofuel has an
inherited compound that are corrosive in nature.Oxygen gas or liquid present in
the gas stream or bio-fuel readily reactance to other elements that causes
oxidation.
Ethanol tester/ Water Hybrid u   |2009-10-09 09:57:59
These people blaming water as the cause of corrosion are all ignorant and did
not do any actual testing at all. It is not water that corroded the carburetor
jets that is made of copper alloy (brass), it is ethanol. The copper alloy does
not corrode with water, we use the same copper alloy sa mga gripo for several
years at walang corrosion ang mga ito.

Majority of vehicles in the
Philippines are designed without ethanol in mind. Just because naging uso ang
ethanol sa ibang bansa, it does not mean pwede na ito sa bansa natin. You also
have to consider kung anong vehicles ang gamit nila when using ethanol. It
would be better we will make use of water as alternative source of fuel rather
than ethanol. Unfortunately, people in government specially the Department of
Energy and DOST (Department of "Sayang" ang Technology) are not
interested with this concept. Binaha na tayo ng tubig, kailan pa natin gamitin
ito as fuel?
I_Want_Change  - Re: Water Hybrid u   |2009-10-09 10:53:11
Hindi ba mas mahal yung water hybrid kasi papalitan yung entire engine??? At
malamang hindi lang copper alloy ang nasa carburetor. Yung mga gripo may coating
pa yan of other chemicals.

Kung successful yung ibang bansa sa ethanol-fueled
automobiles, bakit hindi kaya dito? I bet yung mga gas companies nag-ssabotage
sa success na yan kasi lugi sila! Sinasabi nila na wala silang tamang formula
for the e10 blend para hindi maging corrosive. Bakit hindi nila kunin sa ibang
bansa na hindi nag-corrode yung mga engines???
WaterHybrid User   |2009-10-09 15:50:30
Kindly browse the following discussion groups, meron topic about ethanol from
real users
at merong topic on how to use water as alternative source of
fuel:

http://tsikot.yehey.com/forums/forumdispl ay.php?f=136
WaterHybrid User   |2009-10-09 15:51:53
You don't have to change your engine and you don't have to spend too much to use
water as alternative source of fuel like hydrogen. You don't even buy the water
that you will use dahil laging may ulan sa country natin.

Kung magawa natin
na ma implement ang GEET sa mga vehicles natin, di na tayo mag problema pa sa sa
fuel kahit may ethanol pa ito. This is not to stop from using gasoline or
diesel, this is only to make use of such fuels as efficient as possible and we
can even extend it by using water for better combustion and a cleaner exhaust.


http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:GEET_Re actor_by_Paul_Pantone

This
technology has been suppressed at sinira ng tudo but you cannot stop anyone from
implementing it using the given free plans.
I_Want_Change  - re:   |2009-10-12 08:22:25
WaterHybrid User wrote:

This technology has been suppressed at sinira ng tudo but you cannot stop
anyone from implementing it using the given free plans.


Look, it's really the same as ethanol. Do you hear complaints of other
countries who have been using ethanol for years and with higher
ethanol blend?? Why is it just here in the Philippines? Water hybrid
and ethanol technologies have worked successfully in other countries. And
they've been BOTH suppressed and damaged by media, gas companies, car
companies, government, etc. There are conspiracies that the public do not
realize. People reject a product right away when there are negative
results. People should ask WHY it's not working and DO something about it.
Anonymous   |2009-11-15 00:58:27
e10 sucks ......water off the air and also filipinos ....give us a choice we
want non e10 thats democracy
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
:angry::0:confused::cheer:B):evil::silly::dry::lol:
:kiss::D:pinch::(:shock::X:side::):P
:unsure::woohoo::huh::whistle:;):s:!::?::idea:
:arrow:
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."